Wishlist
Book Summary
Thomas Leitch's Film Adaptation and Its Discontents examines the cultural and aesthetic biases against film adaptations, arguing that adaptation is a legitimate creative practice rather than a lesser copy. Through case studies and theoretical analysis, Leitch challenges the hierarchy that privileges literature over cinema, offering a nuanced defense of adaptation as an art form in its own right.
This book is not available
Store  |
Condition |
Deals & Coupons | Price |
Est. Shipping |
Total |
Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sorry we could not find any result for “9780801885655” | ||||||
About Film Adaptation and Its Discontents...
In Film Adaptation and Its Discontents, Thomas Leitch delivers a rigorous and provocative analysis of the enduring prejudice against film adaptations. Moving beyond simple fidelity criticism, Leitch explores why adaptations are often dismissed as derivative, tracing this bias to Romantic notions of authorship and cultural hierarchies that privilege literature over cinema. Through a series of insightful case studies—from classic novels to contemporary bestsellers—he demonstrates how adaptations engage in complex intertextual dialogues, reshaping source material to reflect new cultural contexts. Leitch argues that adaptation is not a secondary or parasitic practice but a vital mode of creative expression with its own aesthetic principles. The book combines theoretical sophistication with accessible prose, making a compelling case for reevaluating how we judge adapted works. It is an essential contribution to adaptation studies, offering both a history of the field's anxieties and a forward-looking framework for appreciating adaptations on their own terms.
Who should read Film Adaptation and Its Discontents...?
This book is essential for film scholars, literature students, and anyone interested in adaptation studies. It suits academics and graduate students exploring intertextuality and cultural hierarchy, as well as cinephiles and book lovers who want to move beyond fidelity debates. Teachers of film and literature will find it a valuable resource for classroom discussion, and general readers curious about why adaptations provoke such strong reactions will appreciate Leitch's engaging and accessible arguments.
Pros & Cons
Pros
- ✓ Offers a sophisticated theoretical framework for analyzing film adaptations beyond fidelity criticism.
- ✓ Provides insightful case studies that illustrate complex ideas with concrete examples.
- ✓ Challenges deeply ingrained cultural biases against adaptation as a creative practice.
- ✓ Written in clear, engaging prose suitable for both scholars and general readers.
- ✓ Serves as a foundational text in the field of adaptation studies, synthesizing key debates.
Cons
- ✗ Assumes some familiarity with literary and film theory, which may challenge beginners.
- ✗ Focuses primarily on Western canonical texts, limiting its cultural scope.
- ✗ Some readers may find the theoretical discussions dense or abstract.
- ✗ The case studies, while insightful, do not cover a wide range of global cinema.
- ✗ Lacks a comprehensive bibliography of adaptation studies beyond the author's selected references.
Similar books
Frequently asked questions
Is this book primarily about film theory or literary analysis?
It bridges both fields, focusing on the intersection of literature and film through adaptation studies, with an emphasis on cultural and theoretical debates.
Does the author argue that all adaptations are equally good?
No, Leitch does not claim all adaptations are successful; rather, he argues that adaptations should be evaluated on their own terms, not solely by fidelity to the source.
Can this book be used in an undergraduate course?
Yes, it is often assigned in film and literature courses, though instructors may need to provide background on theoretical concepts for beginners.
What types of adaptations are discussed in the book?
The book covers a range of adaptations, primarily from literature to film, including classic novels, popular fiction, and some stage-to-film examples, with a focus on Anglo-American texts.
Is this a practical guide for screenwriters adapting novels?
Not directly; it is a scholarly analysis of adaptation as a cultural practice, though screenwriters may find its insights valuable for understanding adaptation's creative potential.
At Windsorbooks, we compare prices from trusted sellers so you can buy, rent, or sell textbooks at the best total price — shipping included.
As an Amazon Associate, Windsorbooks.com may earn a small commission on qualifying purchases.